Olive Oil: Without a doubt, use the best olive oil you can get your hands on. If you want to lean into ingredients from North African or the Middle East, purchase extra-virgin olive oil from those regions. The brand Mina is a good example of a single-origin Moroccan oil.
Ground Cumin: This is one of the important spices for this recipe. Cumin is powerful in taste and fragrance. It contributes heavily to the undertones in this dish. Feel free to use cumin seeds and grind them in a mortar and pestle or spice grinder to maximize freshness.
Ground Coriander: Coriander is more subtle than cumin, but still stands proud in a complex dish of umami, sweet, punchy flavor. It’s a little floral but not as powerful as cilantro.
Smoked Paprika: It’s one of my favorite spices to use, so I wanted to include it here. I’ve seen it left out of other shakshuka recipes, but some use either the sweet or smoked form. I recommend you go smokey on this one.
Caraway Seeds: I feel it’s not as common to find ground caraway as it is their seeds. The seeds are totally fine to consume—make sure to toast them ahead of time. I included it here because it’s a common ingredient in harissa paste. Also, carraway has a licorice essence and is another important flavor to build on top of the others in this recipe.
Bell Pepper: An integral ingredient in shakshuka, bell peppers add a little texture and sweetness.
Yellow Onion: I included onion since it’s a staple ingredient in shakshouka and also brings out some sweetness as it breaks down into the sauce.
Roma Tomatoes: Instead of using only canned crushed tomatoes or canned whole tomatoes, I wanted to add variety with cooked down pieces of fresh tomato. If you don’t have one on hand, you can use whole canned tomatoes. You can also use beefsteak.
Jalapeño: I opted for these since they’re the easiest chiles to find. You could also use serrano or habanero depending on how spicy you’d like this to be. If you don’t have access to fresh chiles, you can use cayenne pepper.
Garlic: Another very important staple. Use lots of garlic and chop it pretty finely so it evenly disperses through the sauce.
Crushed Tomatoes: I went for canned crushed to balance the fresh chunkier tomatoes that are in here. Feel free to use whole canned and crush yourself in a food processor or with an immersion blender.
Large Eggs: The star of this dish are the eggs. I use large since they’re the Delish go-to. If you go smaller, you may have room to add more in the sauce. If you go larger, then you may have to subtract 1 or 2.
Feta: Lean into Middle East/Israeli ingredients by using feta. It’s a lovely briny and salty addition.
Cilantro: I love how vibrant cilantro is, and it works great with feta, tomato, and on eggs. Only use a small amount so it doesn’t take over the more milder flavors. If you aren’t a fan, you can omit.